The Verdict

1982 | Courtroom Drama | 129 minutes | In English


Frank Galvin is a has-been lawyer and a big time alcoholic. He spends his time in bars and playing pinball machines. Out of compassion, Mickey Morrissey, his friend and former teacher, throws him a malpractice case. The supposed negligence  during surgery at a  Catholic hospital ended up with the woman patient brain-dead. Mickey assures Frank that this is the kind of case that’s always settled. With little work, Frank can make a quick buck. But after Frank visits the comatose patient, he decides not to settle and take the case to trial. The patient’s relatives are furious as is the presiding judge. Mickey agrees to help Frank but things quickly go wrong. The vital medical expert they counted on disappears; the credentials of the back-up medical expert are questioned; no one who was in the operating room is willing to testify; and the hospital is being represented by high-powered and well-connected lawyer, Ed Concannon. Frank’s break comes when he discovers that the admitting nurse, Kaitlin Costello, is now a pre-school teacher and is willing to testify. Her testimony reveals the hospital’s negligence. But the clever Concannon convinces the judge to throw it out the testimony on a technicality. Frank is now left with no case but he does give a passionate closing statement. As Frank awaits the jury’s decision, he feels he has done his best. And, more importantly, by fighting the hospital rather than accepting its settlement, he has regained his lost self-esteem.

Paul Newman (Frank Galvin) / Jack Warden (Mickey Morrissey) / James Mason (Ed Concannon) / Lindsay Crouse (Kaitlin Costello)
Why Stream This Film?
First, it’s to see Paul Newman give one of the best performances of his career. Yes, it’s a courtroom drama, but it’s more a film about character and redemption. It’s about a has-been alcoholic refusing to take a quick settlement but instead seizing the opportunity to recapture his dignity and self-esteem. The film is more a character study than a thriller. In the hands of writer David Mamet and director Sidney Lumet, it works and is brilliant.  
  • Rotten Tomatoes Score (Critics Consensus): 93%
  • Metacritic Score: 77
  • Academy Awards: Nominated, Best Picture; Best Actor (Paul Newman); Best Actor in a SupportingRole (James Mason); Best Director (Sidney Lumet); Best Adapted Screenplay (David Mamet)

Now streaming on:

The screenplay by David Mamet is a wonder of good dialogue, strongly seen characters and a structure that pays off in the big courtroom scene—as the genre requires. Frank Galvin provides Paul Newman with the occasion for one of his great performances.
Roger Ebert

Chicago Sun-Times

A solidly old-fashioned courtroom drama such as THE VERDICT could have gotten by with a serious, measured performance from its leading man, or it could have worked well with a dazzling movie-star turn. The fact that Paul Newman delivers both makes a clever, suspenseful, entertaining movie even better.
Janet Maslin

The New York Times

Newman’s portrayal of his character is a sympathetic and totally candid performance. Every wart shows, from his alcoholism to the ill-prepared opening statement he delivers in a nervous stammer to the packed courtroom. Small moments come across as something special, and the actor received a well-deserved Oscar nomination for his performance.

TV Guide

Anatomy of a Murder

Anatomy of a Murder

Paul Biegler, a retired small-time Michigan lawyer, is contacted by Laura Manion and asked to defend her husband, Lt. Frederick Manion. Pushed by his alcoholic mentor and friend, Parnell McCarthy, Biegler agrees to take the case. Lt. Manion was arrested…

read more
Breaker Morant

Breaker Morant

This true story is set in South Africa during the Second Boer War (1899-1902). The Boers were Dutch colonialists and their descendants who were battling the British for more control and influence in South Africa…

read more
The Caine Mutiny

The Caine Mutiny

Commander Queeg’s minesweeper, the “USS Caine,” is informed that a typhoon is approaching. It hits the “Caine” forcefully, creating damage and panic. The rolling sea threatens to capsize the “Caine”…

read more

If you found this site helpful, please recommend it to a friend. We also welcome your comments. / call 917-439-3364

P.O. Box 20038
New York, N.Y. 10075


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Tired of searching for what to stream?

Join our free email newsletter! A curated selection of the best TV shows and movies available, focusing on a different subject, genre, or theme every Friday.

You have Successfully Subscribed!